Upgrade the two main weapons you are actively using first. Explore for materials before buying large quantities, and read each newly unlocked move so that the upgrade changes how you fight rather than only the displayed number.
Where to start
Reach Forge at the Weeping Creek Valley outpost and inspect the weapon upgrade options. Choose a weapon whose timing you can use reliably; an unfamiliar weapon is not automatically better just because another player recommends it. Use Bells to return between exploration and upgrades.
Weapons can gain additional abilities as they level. After each upgrade, review the weapon’s move description and try the new action against a manageable enemy before relying on it against a boss.
Upgrade milestones and reforging cost
Weapons and Phantom Edges gain an active or passive ability every five upgrade levels; read the new description after upgrading. PC Gamer reports reforging is free through level 10, while higher levels require a reforge talisman, and returns the materials and Remnant Dust spent. Check the displayed cost and return before confirming. One-handed and two-handed weapons use different upgrade materials, so pairing them can spread demand across resources.
Reforging and switching builds
GamesRadar reports that reverting a weapon to level 1 returns its spent upgrade materials. If you want to replace your active weapon, inspect the reforging screen and the return shown there before confirming. Keep track of any other costs displayed by the game rather than assuming every resource or associated choice works identically.
A practical approach is to keep one weapon for guard pressure and another whose damage pattern suits the target. Switch between them during safe moments to refill Sha-Chi, not only when changing your build in a menu.
Soul Tempering is a separate step
Some Phantom Edges or weapons have later Soul Tempering requirements involving specific items. For example, the Blood Oath Dagger is linked to tempering the Dread Axe. Ordinary upgrade materials and a unique quest item are not interchangeable; read the current recipe before using either.
Sources: GamesRadar upgrades and PlayStation weapon overview.
Sources
Revision history
— Recently updated