Four Fierce Axes begins with a case file in Broken Puppet Valley. The evidence trail continues after Peng Meng and is not finished during your first pass through Weeping Creek Valley: the final file requires later progress to the Village of Lu.
Start the investigation
Search the house near the Broken Puppet Valley Bell for a case file, and investigate the body by the nearby shrine. Continue through the outpost route and defeat Peng Meng; the quest then asks you to gather evidence of the conspiracy.
Follow the marked evidence
The evidence locations include a table along the route between Rustblade Pavilion and the outpost courtyard, another near the Axemaster’s Holding Cell, and a table in the lower Sha-Chi Tower forge. To reach the tower area, first obtain the Hunter’s Chain Sickle and the tower base-camp key from the top of the tower.
One file comes through a different quest. After defeating Peng Meng, use the Dread Axe on the outpost barrier, speak to the captain and carry the letter to the lieutenant at Long Pillar Overlook. Follow the journal markers for the evidence you still need.
After obtaining the Hunter’s Chain Sickle, reach the top of Sha-Chi Tower and collect the base-camp key. Use it on the locked door near the Creek Valley Plains Entrance Bell. The forge on the lower level contains a case file; the unlocked area also leads to the lieutenant who receives the captain’s letter.
Why the last file is missing
Continue to the Village of Lu after Crimson Forest. The Leave None Alive quest sends you back to the outpost; a previously inaccessible route then opens. Go through the houses and Lady’s Cave, and use the Hunter’s Chain Sickle outside to reach the remaining file.
Deliver the evidence and claim the reward
When the remaining evidence is collected, follow the Pangzhen marker to the building near the Pavilion of Knowledge Crossroads Bell. Defeat the guards, fight through three floors of masked enemies and take the roof key. Open the top-floor door and speak to the Child of Insight on the roof about the Axemaster to receive the Blood Oath Dagger. The dagger is used to Soul Temper the Dread Axe after the relevant forge option is unlocked.
Source: PC Gamer case-file walkthrough.
Sources
Revision history
— Recently updated