Missed a collectible? You can return through Mission Replay after the game gives you access to Logan’s Nightmare Cabin. PlayStation says level-specific trophies and collectibles can be obtained through replay, so a missed item does not require starting the whole story over.
Missed a collectible? You can return through Mission Replay after the game gives you access to Logan’s Nightmare Cabin. PlayStation says level-specific trophies and collectibles can be obtained through replay, so a missed item does not require starting the whole story over.
This guide is for PS5. Mission names can reveal story events, so stop scrolling the mission list at your current progress if you want to avoid spoilers. Access to the cabin depends on story progress; follow your game’s current prompts.
Find the missing mission
- Open the pause menu during a mission and look for its collectible tracker. Note which category is incomplete before leaving the level.
- When Nightmare Cabin is available, enter it and interact with the bed to open mission selection. The selection screen also shows per-mission collectible information.
- Pick the mission with an incomplete category. Do not replay everything at once: choosing one mission gives you a smaller area to search and a clear result to check afterward.
Search with a purpose
Before moving on from a room or combat area, use Logan’s senses and look around side routes and reachable spaces. Match what you find against the missing category shown by the tracker. If you have unlocked the relevant Crate Finder or Whisky Finder Adaptation, consider equipping it to help locate that type; read its in-game description first.
When you pick up the missing item, check the mission tracker. If you cannot see the count change, verify that it was the right category and that the pickup completed. For a Nightmare Door, interact with the door rather than assuming that seeing it from a distance counted as discovery.
Before leaving replay
Read the game’s warning about leaving the replay and its save behavior. The supplied official guide confirms that collectibles can be obtained through Mission Replay but does not spell out every early-exit save case, so do not assume unfinished mission progress is retained. If in doubt, finish the replay or follow the on-screen instruction, then return to mission selection and confirm the collectible count.
Already-discovered Nightmare Trials can also be replayed from the cabin. Choose the one you need after confirming it is available; replaying a mission and replaying a trial are different activities.
Sources: PlayStation player guide: Mission Replay, PowerPyx collectible tracking and finder Adaptations, Insider Gaming: replaying missions.